Is your brand in the data that trains ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity?Check your domain free
855.629.6584

The eCommerce SEO Conversation Nobody Wants to Have About Their Product Catalog

⏱ 8:00Solo episode · Hosted by Brian Winum
MAXVolume Episode 10: Your Product Catalog Is Killing Your Rankings. MAXPlaces title card with a red and blue waveform on a navy background.
Listen to this episode
The eCommerce SEO Conversation Nobody Wants to Have About Their Product Catalog
Streamed from Podbean - loads only when you press play

Brian Winum explains how product catalogs can complicate eCommerce SEO. He covers faceted navigation, product descriptions and variants, thin and discontinued pages, useful category pages, and a practical order for catalog cleanup as search and AI discovery evolve.

Key Takeaways

01Review the catalog before adding more pages. Map how products, categories, variants, and filters help customers find and choose what they need.
02Decide which filter combinations have independent search value. Control unnecessary crawl paths while preserving useful landing pages.
03Improve priority product pages with information buyers can use. Give variants a deliberate URL, canonical, and structured-data setup.
04Separate temporary stock shortages from permanent retirement. Assess demand, links, and replacement options before consolidating or removing pages.
05Give important category pages a purpose. Add context that helps customers compare products and understand the range.
06Prioritize cleanup and measure the results. Useful product information matters more than simply generating descriptions at scale.

Show notes

Brian Winum opens with a catalog problem that more content and more backlinks may leave unresolved. Product pages, filters, variants, and categories can accumulate without a clear plan for how buyers or crawlers should move through them. His starting point for eCommerce SEO is to examine that structure before expanding it.

Faceted navigation comes first. Useful shopping filters can create many combinations of URLs, including combinations with little independent search value. Brian recommends reviewing which filter pages deserve to be discoverable and which simply multiply the crawl space. A store should make those decisions around real demand and the usefulness of each landing page.

Product descriptions and variant pages need the same deliberate approach. Brian challenges stores that rely on manufacturer copy without adding information that helps a customer decide. He also asks whether separate color and size URLs serve a useful purpose. A canonical tag can help identify a preferred URL among similar pages, but variants still need a setup that fits the store and its products.

Next comes the long tail of thin, unavailable, and discontinued products. Brian describes reviewing pages that no longer serve customers and deciding what to improve, combine, or retire. Content pruning should follow an assessment of demand, links, product history, and replacement options. Temporary stock shortages need different treatment from permanent removal.

Category pages are another priority. A list of products alone may leave customers without the information they need to compare a range or choose the right option. Brian recommends giving important categories useful context, clear organization, and a role in the buying journey. Start with the categories and products that matter most to the business.

The episode then connects catalog quality to AI discovery. Brian discusses clear product information, reviews, and structured data as part of making a catalog easier to interpret. Schema markup can describe product attributes and offers, while visible, accurate product information remains essential. This is a reason to maintain the underlying catalog rather than treat AI visibility as a separate publishing task.

Brian closes with two cautions: bulk-generated descriptions need useful product knowledge, and catalog cleanup needs a plan. His examples illustrate the value of reviewing an existing catalog before adding more pages. Begin with filter behavior, important products, variants, category pages, and retirement rules, then measure the effect of the changes you make.

Chapters

Host

Brian Winum
Solo episode

Brian Winum is a partner at MAXPlaces and MAXBURST with more than 20 years in digital marketing. On MAXVolume, he examines AI search, SEO, and what changes in online discovery mean for businesses.

About Brian Winum →

Full transcript

1,234 words · Full transcript from supplied captions

Transcript provided from the episode subtitles. Select a timestamp to play from that point.

00:10

The catalog conversation

Brian

Here's the conversation I have with eCommerce clients that nobody actually wants to have. They come to me wanting more traffic, more rankings, more revenue — and they want to talk about keywords, or content, or links. And I have to gently steer them toward the thing they've been avoiding, the thing sitting in the corner of every eCommerce operation like a garage nobody's cleaned out in five years. Your product catalog. Because here's the uncomfortable truth: most eCommerce SEO problems aren't a traffic problem or a content problem. They're a catalog problem. And until you're willing to open that garage door and really look at what's in there, nothing else you do is going to stick.

Brian

I'm Brian Winum, this is MAXVolume, and today is for anyone running SEO on a store with more than a handful of products — the eCommerce catalog conversation, and why the thing you've been avoiding is usually the thing holding you back.

01:08

A warehouse that buyers can navigate

Brian

So let me set the frame, because it changes how you see everything after this. Picture your catalog as a giant warehouse, and Google — or an AI assistant — is a buyer walking the aisles with a limited amount of time. In a well-run warehouse, every aisle leads somewhere, every product is clearly labeled, the good stuff is easy to find.

Brian

In most eCommerce catalogs I open up, it's the opposite. Aisles that loop back on themselves. The same product shown twelve slightly different ways. Thousands of empty boxes — products discontinued years ago — still sitting on the shelves. And generic labels copied straight off the manufacturer's sheet, identical to every competitor's. The buyer gives up long before they ever find what's worth buying.

01:55

Faceted navigation and crawl space

Brian

Let me start with the biggest one, and it's the one that sounds the most boring, which is exactly why it gets ignored: faceted navigation. Those filters on your category pages — color, size, price, brand. Every combination a customer can click often generates its own unique web address. Red, size medium, under fifty dollars — that's a page. Now multiply every filter by every other filter, and you don't have a thousand product pages, you have potentially millions of crawlable pages, almost all of them junk variations of each other.

Brian

And here's what that does: Google shows up with a limited crawl budget, spends it wandering through those millions of filter combinations, and never reliably gets to the pages that actually matter. You didn't have too little for Google to find. You buried the good stuff under an avalanche of near-duplicates.

02:49

Product descriptions and variants

Brian

The second one is the conversation that stings, because it means rewriting things. Your product descriptions. On most stores, the product copy is whatever the manufacturer handed you — the exact same paragraph that's on your site, and your competitor's site, and two hundred other retailers' sites all selling the identical item. To a search engine, and to an AI trying to decide who to cite, that copy is worthless for telling you apart. There's nothing there that's actually yours.

Brian

Add in the variant problem — the same shirt in six colors as six separate indexable pages, all nearly identical — and you're not just duplicating the whole internet, you're duplicating yourself. You cannot out-rank anyone on text that belongs to everyone.

03:34

Thin and discontinued product pages

Brian

Third, and this is where the garage really starts to smell: thin pages and zombie pages. The thin ones are products with a title, a price, one stock photo, and maybe three words of description — and you've got thousands of them. Individually harmless. In bulk, they drag down the quality signal of your entire domain, because Google is judging the whole site, not just your best pages.

Brian

The zombies are worse: discontinued products, out-of-stock seasonal items, old listings, all left to rot — returning thin pages or soft errors, quietly telling the engine your store is full of dead ends. Nobody wants to decide what to kill. So it all just accumulates, year after year.

04:21

Give category pages a purpose

Brian

And here's the one that's almost backwards from what people expect. The pages that usually matter most for eCommerce SEO — the big commercial searches, the "running shoes for flat feet," the "stand mixers for bread" — those are your category and subcategory pages, not your individual products. The category page is the money page.

Brian

And on most stores it's the single most neglected thing in the catalog: just a bare grid of products with no real content, no guidance, nothing that actually answers the question behind the search. Everybody pours attention into the homepage or into individual products, and leaves the exact pages built to win the highest-value searches completely empty.

05:05

Prioritize catalog cleanup

Brian

So what's the actual work? It's unglamorous, and that's exactly why nobody wants the conversation. You prune — you decide what to cut, what to consolidate, what to properly retire, and you stop being precious about pages that earn nothing. You get faceted navigation under control, so crawlers spend their budget on the pages that matter instead of filter noise.

Brian

You write genuinely unique descriptions on the products and categories that actually drive revenue — not all ten thousand, the ones that count. You build your category pages into real pages that answer the search. And you handle discontinued products deliberately, instead of letting them rot. None of that is exciting. All of it works. It's cleaning the garage — and the whole store works better the moment you do.

05:54

Product information in AI answers

Brian

And this matters even more as buyers shift to asking AI assistants what to buy. When someone asks an assistant to recommend a product, the AI is leaning on structured product data, on genuine reviews, and on descriptions that actually say something distinctive. A catalog full of manufacturer boilerplate and thin, half-dead pages gives an answer engine nothing to grab onto, so it recommends the retailer whose catalog it can actually understand.

Brian

A clean, well-structured catalog doesn't just rank better in Google — it's the one the AI can read, trust, and put in front of a buyer. Same cleanup, two payoffs.

06:35

Useful copy and retirement decisions

Brian

Now let me be honest, because eCommerce is crawling with people selling shortcuts. The big one right now is bulk AI-generated product descriptions — spin up unique-looking copy for ten thousand products at the push of a button. Be careful. If everyone's running the same tools on the same products, you've just recreated the duplicate-content problem in a new costume: thin content at scale. The goal was never "unique-looking text," it was genuinely useful information, and that still takes real work on the pages that matter.

Brian

And here's the hardest truth of all: more is not better. I have watched stores delete tens of thousands of thin and dead pages and watch their rankings go up, because the whole domain finally looked like a place worth trusting. Sometimes the fix for your catalog is a lot less catalog.

07:27

Start the catalog review

Brian

That's the eCommerce SEO work we do at MAXPlaces — having the catalog conversation nobody wants to have, and then doing the unglamorous cleanup that actually moves revenue: the crawl control, the pages worth writing, the category pages built to win, and the honest decisions about what to retire. If your store has quietly grown into a warehouse nobody's organized in years, that is usually where your traffic went. Come find us at MAXPlaces.

Brian

I'm Brian Winum. Thanks for turning it up. I'll see you next time.

Ready to be the answer AI recommends?

Start with a free check to see whether your website appears in Common Crawl, a primary source of training data for AI models. For a deeper assessment of your AI visibility and actionable recommendations, explore our paid AI Readiness Audit.

Prefer to talk now? Call 855.629.6584 — or if none of the times work, just reply and we'll find one.